The manager as a teacher: selected aspects of stimulation of scientsfsc thinking
Stabilization systems and
proportional systems. There exist a great number of types of various systems.
But stabilization systems and proportional systems are of special importance
for us. In respect of the first one the result of action always remains the
same (stable), it does not depend on the force of external influence, but on
the command. For example, ðÍ of blood should be always equal to 7.4, blood
pressure to 120/80 mm Hg, etc., (homeostasis systems) regardless of external
influences. In respect of the second one the result of action depends on the
force of external influence under any specific law designated by the command and
is proportional to it. For example, the more physical work we perform the more
Î2
we
should consume and excrete ÑÎ2. Stabilization system uses two
receptors, “Õ” and “Y”. The “Õ” receptor is used to start up the system
depending on the presence of external influence, while the “Y” receptor is used
for the measurement of the result of action. The command (the task specifying
the value of the result of action) is entered to the command entry point of the
stabilization system’s control block. Stabilization system should fulfill this
task, i.e. support (stabilize) the result of action at the designated level
irrespective of the force of external influence. Stability of the result of
action is ensured by that the “database” of the control block contains the ratios/correlations
of the number of active SFU and forces of external influence and is sustained
according to the NF logic: if the result of action has increased, it is
necessary to reduce it, and if it has decreased it’s necessary to increase it.
For this purpose the control block should contain DPC and NF. Hence, the
elementary control block (DPC) is not suitable for stabilization systems. At
least simple control block which contains NF as well is necessary. In
stabilization system the result of action of the system up to vertical dotted
straight line is stable (normal function, the curve goes horizontally). Beyond
the dotted straight line the function goes down (increases), stabilization was
disturbed (insufficiency of function). With proportional system, its function
increases (goes down) until vertical dotted straight line proportionally to the
external influence (normal function). Beyond the dotted straight line the
function does not vary (it entered the saturation phase, transited to a plateau
condition - insufficient function). The measuring element in stabilization
system continually measures the result of action of the system and communicates
it to the control block which compares it to the preset result. In case of
discrepancy of the result of action with the task this block makes decision on
those or other actions to be taken and forces the executive elements to operate
so that this divergence has disappeared. External influence may vary within
various ranges, but the result of action should remain stable and be equal to
the preset result. The system spends its resources to do it. If the resources
are exhausted, stabilization system ceases to stabilize the result of action
and starting from this point the onset of its insufficiency occurs. One of
stabilization examples is stellar rotation speed in vacuum. If the radius of
the star reduces, its rotational speed will increase and centrifugal forces
will amplify, thus scaling up its radius and slowing down its rotational speed.
If the radius of the star scales up, the entire process will go in a reverse
order. A figure skater regulates the speed of rotational pirouettes he/she
performs on the skating-rink based on the same principle. Proportional system
should also use both “Õ” and “Y” receptors. One of them measures the incoming
influence, while another one measures the result of action of the system. The
command (the task as to what the proportion between external influence and the
result of action should be) is input to the entry point of the control block.
It is for this reason that such systems are called proportional. External
influence may change within the varying range. But the control block should
adjust the performance of the executive elements so that the “prescribed”
(preset by the directive) proportion between external influence and the result
of action is maintained. Examples of proportional systems are, for example,
amplifiers of electric signals, mechanical levers, sea currents (the more the
water in the ocean is warmed up, the more intensive is the flow in the Gulf
Stream), atmospheric phenomena, etc. So, the examples of stabilization and
proportional systems are found in any medium, but not only in biological
systems.
Active and passive systems.
Passive systems are those which do not exspend energy for their actions. Active
systems are those which do exspend energy for their actions. However, as it was
repeatedly underlined, any action of any system requires expenditure of energy.
Any action, even the most insignificant, is impossible without expenditure of
energy, because, as it has already been mentioned, any action is always the
interaction between systems or its elements. Any interaction represents
communication between the systems or their elements which requires expenditure
of energy for the creation thereof. Therefore any action requires energy
consumption. Hence, all systems, including passive, consume energy. The
difference between active and passive systems is only in the source of energy.
How does the passive system operate then? If the system is in the state of
equilibrium with the environment and no influence is exerted upon it the system
should not perform any actions. Once it does not perform any actions, it does
not consume energy. It is passive until the moment it starts to operate and
only then it will start to consume energy. The balanced state of a
pencil is stipulated by the balanced pushing (pressure) of springs onto a
pencil. The springs are not simply incidental groups of elements (a set of
atoms and molecules), but they are passive systems with NF loops and executive
elements at molecular level (intermolecular forces in steel springs) which seek
to balance forces of intermolecular connections/bonds which is manifested in
the form of tension load of the springs. Since in case of the absence of
external influence no actions are performed by the system, there is no energy
consumption either, and the system passively waits for the onset of external
influence. Both types of systems have one and the same goal: to keep a pencil
in vertical position. In passive systems this function is carried out by
springs (passive SFU, A and B) and air columns encapsulated/encased in rubber
cans (passive SFU, D). The SFU store (use) energy during external influence
(pushing a pencil with a finger squeezes the springs). In active system (C) the
same function is achieved for at the expense of airflows which always collapse.
These airflows create motor fans (active SFU) which spend energy earlier
reserved, for example, in accumulators. Once these airflows are
encapsulated/encased in rubber cylinders they will not collapse any more and
will exist irrespective of fans, while carrying out the same function. But now
it represents a passive system (D). Now external influence occurs and the
pencil has diverged aside. The springs would immediately seek to return a
pencil to the former position, i.e. the system starts to operate. Where does it
take energy for the actions from? This energy was brought by the external
influence in the form of kinetic energy of pushing by a finger which has
compressed (stretched) the springs and they have reserved this energy in the
form of potential energy of compression (stretching). As soon as external
influence (pushing by a finger) has ceased, potential energy of the compressed
springs turns to kinetic energy of straightening thereof and it returns a
pencil back in the vertical balanced position. External influence enhances internal
energy of the system which is used for the performance of the system. The
influence causes surplus of internal energy of the system which results in the
reciprocal action of the system. In the absence of influence no surplus of the
system’s internal energy is available which results in the absence of action.
External influence brings in the energy in the system which is used to produce
reaction to this influence. Functions of springs may be performed by airflows
created by fans located on a pencil. In order to “build” airflows surplus of
energy of the “fans – pencil” system is used which is also brought in from the
outside, but stored for use at the right time (for example, gasoline in the
tank or electricity in accumulator). Such system would be active because it
will use its internal energy, rather than that of external influence. The
difference between airflows and springs consists in that the airflows consist
of incidental groups of molecules of air (not systems) moving in one direction.
Amongst these elements there are executive elements (SFU, air molecules), but
there is no control block which could construct a springs-type system out of
them, i.e. provide the existence of airflows as stable, separate and
independent bodies (systems). These airflows are continually created by fan
propellers and as they have no control block of their own they always collapse
by themselves. Suppose that we construct some kind of a system which will
ensure prevention of the airflows from collapse, let’s say, encase them in
rubber cylinders, they then may exist independently of fans. But in this case
the system of stabilization of the pencil’s vertical position will shift from
the active category to the passive. Hence, both active and passive systems
consume energy. However, the passive ones consume the external energy brought
in by external influence, while the active ones would use their own internal
energy. One may argue that internal energy, say, of myocyte is still the
external energy brought in to a cell from the outside, e.g. in the form of
glucose. It is true, and moreover, any object contains internal energy which at
some stage was external. And we probably may even know the source of this
energy, which is the energy of the Big Bang. Some kind of energy was spent once
and somewhere for the creation of an atom, and this energy may be extracted
therefrom somehow or other. Such brought-in internal energy is present in any
object of our World and it is impossible to find any other object in it which
would contain exclusively its own internal energy which was not brought in by
anything or ever from the outside. Energy exchange occurs every time the
systems interact. But passive systems do not spend their internal energy in the
process of their performance because they “are not able” of doing it, they only
use the energy of the external influence, whereas active systems can spend
their internal energy. The passive system is the thorax
which performs passive exhalation and many other systems of living organism.
Evolution of systems. Complex
control block. For the most efficient achievement of the goal the system always
should carry out its action in the optimum way and produce the result of action
in the right place and time. The system’s control block solves both problems: where
and when it is necessary to actuate. In order to be able to operate at the
right place it should have a notion of space and the corresponding sensors
delivering information on the situation in the given space. In
turn, the time of delivery of the result of action with simple systems includes
two periods: the time spent for decision-making (from the moment of onset of
external influence till the moment of SFU activation) and the time spent for
the
SFU
actuation (from the moment of the beginning of SFU activation till the moment
the result of action is achieved). The time spent for the decision-making
depends on duration of cycles of the system’s performance which issue was
discussed above. The time spent for the SFU actuation depends on
the SFU properties such as, for example, the speed of biochemical reactions in
live cells or the speed of reduction of sarcomere in muscular cells which to a
considerable degree depends on the speed of power consumption by these SFU and
the speed of restoration of energy potential after these SFU have been
actuated. These speeds are basically the characteristics inherent in SFU, but
are also determined by service systems which serve these SFU. They may also be
controlled by control block. Metabolic, hormonal, prostaglandin and vegetative
neural regulation in living organism is intended just for this purpose, i.e. to
change to some extent the speeds of biochemical reactions in tissue cells and
conditions of delivery of energy resources by means of regulation of (service)
respiratory and blood circulation systems. But the notion of “at the right
time” means not only the time of actuation in response to the external
influence. In many cases there is a need for the actuation to start before
external influence is exerted. However, the system with simple control block
starts to perform only after the onset of external influence. It is a very
significant (catastrophic) drawback for living systems, because if the organism
is being influenced upon, it may mean that it is already being eaten. It would
be better if the system started to perform before the onset of this external
influence. If the external situation is threatening by the onset of dangerous
influence, the optimal actions of the system may protect it from such
influence. For this purpose it is necessary to know the condition of external
situation and to be able to see, estimate and know what actions need to be
undertaken in certain cases. In other words, it is necessary to exercise
control in order to forestall real result of action prior to external
influence. In order to perform these actions it should contain special elements
which can do it and which it does not have. Simple control block can exercise
control only on the basis of mismatch (divergence/discrepancy) of real result
of action with the preset one, because the system with simple control block
cannot “know” anything about external situation until the moment this situation
starts to influence upon the system. The knowledge of external situation is
inaccessible to simple control block. Therefore, simple control block always
starts to perform with delay. It may be sometimes too late to control. If the
system (the living organism) does not know the external situation, it may not
be able to make projection as to what the situation is and catch the victim or
forestall encounter with a predator. Thus, simple control block cannot make
decisions on the time and place of actuation. For this purpose control block
needs a special analyzer which can determine and analyze external situation and
depending on various external or internal conditions elaborate the decision on
its actions. This analyzer should have a notion of time and space in which
certain situation is deployed, as well as corresponding informants (sensors
with communication lines between them and this special analyzer) which provide
information on the external situation. The analyzer-informant has nothing of
this kind. When the hunter shoots at a flying duck, it shoots not directly at
the bird, but he shoots with anticipation as he knows that before the bullet
reaches a duck it (the duck) will move forward. The hunter, being a system
intended for shooting a duck, should see the entire situation at a distance,
estimate it correctly, make the projection as to whether it makes sense to
shoot, and he should act, i.e. shoot at a duck, only on the basis of such
analysis. He cannot wait until the duck touches him (until his “X” is actuated)
so that he then can shoot at it. In order to do so he should first single out a
duck as the object he needs from other unnecessary objects, then measure a
distance to a duck, even if it would be “by eye”. He does it by means of
special (visual) analyzer which is neither “X” nor “Y” sensor, but is an
additional “C” sensor (additional special remote receptors with afferent
paths). Such receptors can be any receptors which are able of receiving
information at a distance (haemo-, termo-, photoreceptors, etc). The hunter’s
visual analyzer includes photosensitive rods and cone cells in the eye (photoreceptors),
optic nerves and various cerebral structures. He should be able to distinguish
all surrounding subjects, classify them and single out a duck against the
background of these subjects and locate a duck (situational evaluation). In
addition, by means of reciprocal innervation he should position his body in
such a way that the gun is directed precisely to the place in front of the duck
(forestalling/ anticipation) to achieve the goal, i.e. to hit the duck. He does
all this by means of his additional analyzer which is the analyzer-classifier.
Simple control block of systems with NF does not contain such additional
analyzer-classifier. That is why it is called “simple”. It has only
analyzer-informant which feels external influence by means of “X” sensor only
when this influence has already begun; it measures the result of action by
means of NF (“Y” sensor) only when this result is already evident and analyzes
the information received after the result of action is already produced,
because it takes time for the NF to activate. In addition, the
analyzer-informant contains only “database” in which the table of due values of
controllable parameters (data) which need to be compared to the data of
measurements of external influence and results of action “is written down” in
explicit or implicit form. It elaborates decisions on the basis of these
comparisons. Its algorithm of control is based only on the comparison of the
given measurements carried out by “X” and “Y” with the “database”. If the
mismatch is equal to “M” it is necessary to perform, for example, less action,
whereas if it is equal to “N”, then more action should be done. Simple control
block cannot change the decision as to the alteration of the level of
controllable parameter, time of actuation and the NF intensity, since it does
not have appropriate information. To perform these actions it should contain
special elements which can provide it with such information. What does it need
for this purpose? In order to make a decision the given block should “know” the
situation around the system which can cause certain external influence. For
this purpose it should first of all “see” it, i.e. have sensors
which can receive information at a distance and without direct contact (remote
“C” informant). In addition, it should contain a special analyzer-classifier
which can classify external environment and single out from it not all the
objects and situations, but those only which may affect the implementation of
its goals. Besides, it should have notions of space and time. The play of fish
and even dolphin shoals in the vicinity of floating combatant ship cannot
affect
its
movement to target destination. But the “game” of the enemy submarine in its
vicinity may substantially affect the fulfillment of its task. The combatant
ship should be able to “see” all its surroundings and, based on the external
situation, single out from all possible situations only those that may create
such external influences which can prevent it from the implementation of its
objective. For this purpose it should “know” possible situational scenarios
which may affect the achievement of the goal of the given system. To this
effect it should have “knowledge base” containing the description of all those
situations which can affect the implementation of the objective. If its
“knowledge base” does not have the description of certain objects or situations
it cannot distinguish (classify) an object or a situation and can not make
correct decision. The “knowledge base” should store information not on the
parameters of external influence which are stored in the “database”, but on the
situations around (beyond) the system which may lead to specific external
influence. The “knowledge base” may be introduced in the control block at the
moment of its “birth” or later together with the command, at that it is being
introduced in the given block by the systems external in relation to the given
system. If its “knowledge base” does not contain the description of the given
situation, it can not distinguish and classify it. The “knowledge base”
contains the description of various situations and the significance of these
situations for the system. Knowing the importance of real situation for the
achievement of the goal the system can make projection and take decision on its
actions depending on the projection made. In addition to the “knowledge base”
it should have “decision base”– a set of ready/stored/ decisions that are made
by the control block depending on the situation and the
projection, (authorized decisions, instructions) in which appropriate decisions
are stored that need to be made in respective situations. If it does not have
ready decisions regarding external situation it cannot perform its objective.
Having identified a situation and elaborated the decision, it gives a command
to the analyzer-informant which activates a stimulator in an appropriate way.
Thus, the control block is being complexificated on account of inclusion in its
structure of the “C” informant and the analyzer-classifier containing the
“knowledge base” and the “base of decisions”.
That is why such control blocks are called “complex”. The more complex the
decision-making block is, the more precise decision may be chosen.
Consequently, complex control block includes both the analyzer-informant which
has “database
and the analyzer-classifier which has the “knowledge base” and the “decision
base”. Not any living cell has analyzer - classifier. Animate/organic/ nature
is classified under two major groups: flora and fauna. Plants, as well as many
other living forms of animate nature, such as corals and bacteria, do not
possess remote sensors, although in some cases it may seem that plants,
nevertheless, do have such sensors. For example, sunflowers turn their heads
towards the sun as if phototaxis is inherent in them. But they actually turn
their heads not towards the light, but towards the side wherefrom their bodies
get more heated, and heat comes from the side wherefrom the light comes. Heat
is felt locally by a sunflower’s body. It does not have special infra-red
sensors. Photosynthesis process is not a process of phototaxis. Hence, plants
are systems with simple control block. In spite of the fact that there are
plants with a very complex structure that are even capable to feed on subjects
of fauna, their control block is still simple and reacts only to direct
contact. For example, a sundew feeds on insects; it can entice them, paste them
to its external stomach and even contract its valves. It’s a predator and in
this sense it is akin to a wolf, a shark or a jellyfish. It can do variety of
actions like an animal, but it can only do it after the insect alights on it. A
sundew cannot chase its victims because it does not see them (remote sensors
are not available). Whatever alights on it, even a small stone, it will do all
necessary actions and try to digest it because it does not have
analyzer-classifier. This is why a sundew is a plant, but not an animal.
Animate cells, including unicellular forms, even such as amoeba or infusoria
types, are systems with complex control blocks since
they possess at least one of spatial analyzers – chemotaxis. It is the presence
of remote sensors that differs a cell of an animal from any objects of flora,
in which such sensors controls are not present. Therefore the control block is
a determinant of what kind of nature the given living object belongs to. The
jellyfish is not an alga, but an animal because it has chemotaxis. Remote
analyzer gives an idea about the space in which it has to move. That is why plants
stay put, while animals move in space. Simple control block including only the
analyzer-informant is a determinant of the world of minerals and plants. We
will see below where the difference between the mineral and vegetative
worlds/natures lies. Complex control block including the analyzer-classifier is
a fauna determinant anyway. An amoeba is the same kind of hunter as a wolf, a
shark or a man. It feeds on infusorians. To catch an infusorian it should know
where the latter is and should be able to move. It cannot see the victim at a
distance, but it can feel it by its chemical sense organs and seek to catch it
as it has chemotaxis, possibly the first of the remote sensor mechanisms. But
in addition to chemotaxis the amoeba should also have a notion (even primitive)
of space in which it exists and in which it should move in a coordinated and
task-oriented manner to catch an infusorian. In
addition, it should be able to single out an infusorian from other objects
which it can encounter on its way. Its analyzer-classifier is much simpler
than, for example, that of a wolf or a shark because it does not have organs of
sight and hearing and neural structures at all, but it can classify external
situation. It has complex control block comprising the “C” informant, and that
is why an amoeba is not a plant, but an animal. Since control blocks may be of
any degree of complexity, reflexes may be of any degree of complexity, too,
from elementary axon reflexes to the reflexes including the cerebral cortex
performance (instincts and conditioned reflexes). The number of reflexes of
living organism is enormous and there exist specific reflexes for each system
of the organism. Moreover, the organism is not only a complex system in itself,
but due to its complexity it has a possibility to build additional,
temporary/transient/ systems necessary at the given point of time for some
specific concrete occasion. For example, lamentation system is a temporary
system which the organism builds for a short time interval. The lamentation
system’s control block is the example of complex control block. The purpose of
lamentation is to show one’s suffering and be pitied. This system includes, in
the capacity of composite executive elements, other systems (subsystems) that
are located sufficiently far from each other both in space and in terms of
functions (lacrimal glands, respiratory muscles, alveoli and pulmonary
bronchial tubes, vocal chords, mimic muscles, etc.). At first the external
situation is identified and in case of need lamentation reflex (complex reflex,
an instinct) is actuated under the certain program, which includes control of
lifting up one’s voice up to a certain timbre (control over the respiratory
muscles and vocal chords), sobbing (a series of intermittent sighs), lacrimation
/excretion of tears/, specific facial expression, etc. All these remote
elements are consolidated by the complex control block in a uniform system,
i.e. lamentation system, with very concrete and specific purpose to show one’s
sufferings to the other system. The lamentation reflex can be realized at all
levels of nervous system, starting from the higher central cerebral structures,
including vegetative neural system, subcortex and up to cerebral cortex. But we
are examining only child’s weeping which is realized in neural structures not
higher than subcortex level (instinctive crying). After the purpose has been
achieved (sufferings have been explicitly demonstrated, and whether or not the
child was pitied will be found out later) the reflex is brought to a stop, this
complex control block disappears and the system disintegrates into the
components which now continue functioning as part of other systems of organism.
Lamentation system disappears (it is scattered). Whence the control block (at
subcortex level) knows that it is necessary to cry now, but it is not necessary
to cry at any other moment? For this purpose it identifies a situation (singles
it out and classifies). The analyzer-classifier is engaged in it. Its
“knowledge base” is laid down in subcortex from birth (the instincts). Simple
control block cannot perform such actions. All actions of the systems
controlled by elementary and simple control blocks would be automatic.
Biological analogues of elementary control block are the axon reflexes working
under the “all-or-none” law; those of simple control blocks are unconditional
(innate, instinctive) reflexes when certain automatic, but graduated reaction
occurs in response to certain external influence. Simple control block would be
adapting the system’s actions better than the elementary one because it takes
account of not only external influence, but the result of action of the system
which has occurred in response to this external influence as well. But it
cannot identify a situation. Complex control block can perform such actions. It
reacts not to external influence, but to certain external situation which can
exert certain external influence. Biological analogues of complex control block
are complex reflexes or instincts. During pre-natal development the “knowledge”
of possible situations “is laid down” into the brain of a fetus (the “knowledge
base”). The volume of this knowledge is immense. A chicken can run immediately
after it hardly hatches from egg. A crocodile, a shark or a snake become
predators right after birth, i.e. they know and are able of doing everything
that is required for this purpose. It speaks of the fact that they have
sufficient inborn “knowledge base” and “base of decisions” for this purpose. In
such cases we say that animal has instincts. Thus, the system with complex
control block is the object which can react to certain external situation in
which this influence may be exerted. But it can react only to fixed (finite)
number of external situations which description is contained
in its “knowledge base” and it has a finite number of decisions on these
situations which description is contained in its “base of decisions”. In order
to identify external situation it has the “C” informant and the
analyzer-classifier. In other respects it is similar to the system with simple
control block. It can also react to certain external influence and its reaction
is stipulated by type and number of its SFU. The result of action of the system
is also graduated. The number of gradations is defined by the number of
executive SFU in the system. It also has the analyzer-informant with
the “database”, DPC (the “X” informant) and NF (the “Y” informant), which
control the system through the stimulator (efferent paths). There are no
analogues with complex control block in inorganic /abiocoen, inanimate/ nature.
Biological analogues of systems with complex control block are all animals,
from separate cells to animals with highly developed nervous system including
cerebrum and remote sense organs, such as sight, hearing, sense of smell, but
in which it is impossible to develop reflexes to new situations, for example,
in insects. The analogues of the “C” informant are all “remote” receptors:
eyesight (or its photosensitive analogues in inferior animals),
hearing and sense of smell. The analogues of analyzer-classifier are, for
example, visual, acoustical, gustatory and olfactory analyzers located in the
subcortex. Visual, acoustical, gustatory and olfactory analyzers located in the
cerebral cortex are anyway referred to analyzers-correlators.